Mobile Menu

Wood Fired Pizza, Middleton

Pizza in Middleton

An Italian meal is made better with a large, glorious pizza at the center of the table. To make your lunch or dinner even more special, you can order wood-fired pizza in Middleton, which many people believe is superior to pizza cooked in a conventional oven. Wood-fired pizza in Middleton is a popular dish because of its unique flavors, distinct texture, and classy presentation. Just what is it about wood-fired pizza in Middleton that makes it so irresistible? 

Wood-Fired Pizza in Middleton Simply Tastes Better

To cook wood-fired pizza in Middleton, Benvenuto’s Italian Grill gets a fire going inside an oven. A wood-fired oven gets extremely hot, surpassing temperatures inside regular kitchen ovens. This high heat makes wood-fired pizza in Middleton taste significantly better.

  • Wood-fired pizza in Middleton cooks evenly.

The heat that radiates from the source, which is firewood, spreads evenly inside the oven’s interiors. This kind of environment makes sure that every inch of the pizza gets the same amount of heat. With wood-fired pizza in Middleton, every bite will taste just as good as the next one.

  • Wood-fired pizza in Middleton has a signature taste.

Our method of cooking enhances the flavors of wood-fired pizza in Middleton. You will notice that wood-fired pizza in Middleton has a smoky taste that cannot be replicated by gas or electric ovens. This is why those who seek authentic Italian flavors prefer wood-fired pizza in Middleton.

  • Wood-fired pizza in Middleton is crispy yet soft at the same time.

We’ve all experienced eating soggy pizza even if it just came out of the oven. This happens when the oven is not hot enough to produce the ideal crust texture. With wood-fired pizza in Middleton, you won’t get this result. Wood-fired pizza in Middleton is noticeably crispier, especially if you order the thin-crust variant. While the crust is cooked to crunchy perfection, the insides and toppings remain soft and chewy. This contrast is what makes wood-fired pizza in Middleton a favorite among Italian food lovers. 

Wood-Fired Pizza in Middleton Looks More Appetizing

They say that eating starts with the eyes. You can easily notice the difference between fast-food pizza and wood-fired pizza in Middleton in terms of their presentation. Wood-fired pizza in Middleton looks classier and more enticing thanks to its charred effect. The toppings are assembled more intricately and the cheese oozes out, tingling your taste buds. 

For a fine dining experience that won’t break the bank, Benvenuto’s Italian Grill offers wood-fired pizza for Middleton guests. Impress your date with a candlelit dinner and delicious wood-fired pizza in Middleton that both of you will enjoy. You can learn about why wood fired pizza tastes so good here:

Wood-Fired Pizza in Middleton Is Healthier

Because it is cooked in high temperatures, wood-fired pizza in Middleton is ready after a few minutes in the oven. The vitamins and nutrients in the vegetables are retained, and freshness is preserved. You will not be getting soggy bell peppers or onions with this cooking method. What’s more, the high heat burns off most of the oil in the pizza, which is especially appealing to people trying to reduce their fat intake. You can always drizzle more olive oil on your pizza if you want more moisture and flavor.

Dedicated to the Complete Satisfaction of Our Guests

At Benvenuto’s Italian Grill, we have a commitment to excellence in all aspects of dining, from the food and service to the restaurant ambiance. Our menu has something for everyone, and convenient dining options are available to busy people.

We have a selection of wood-fired pizza in Middleton that includes Formaggio, Three Meat, Benvenuto, and Margherita. Our restaurant uses only high-quality ingredients and sauces seasoned to perfection for our wood-fired pizza in Middleton. You can even choose between hand-tossed or thin-crust pizza. Feel free to upgrade to a cauliflower crust as well. If all of these sound good to you, visit us today and taste the difference of our wood-fired pizza in Middleton!

Benvenuto’s Italian Grill: Your Go-To Restaurant for Classic Italian Dishes

Are you in the mood for traditional Italian cuisine? Satisfy your cravings at Benvenuto’s Italian Grill. We have mastered the art of cooking traditional Italian dishes that are sure to please even the most sophisticated palates. You won’t be able to resist our savory pizzas or our creamy pastas. Lovingly made and perfectly seasoned, our culinary creations will have you savoring every last bite.

Our Story – How the Italian Restaurant You Know and Love Came to Life

Benvenuto’s Italian Grill is a family-owned business in Wisconsin. Since we first opened our doors, we have been committed to providing outstanding food and exceptional service. Founded by Brian and Khristy Dominick, our first restaurant location was established in Beaver Dam, Wisconsin in 1996.

What started out as a dinner-only, Italian dining experience quickly grew into the thriving business it is today. Our menu once included only a handful of pasta dishes and a few wood-fired pizzas. Now, we offer a vast selection of expanded entrée options, individual dishes, and even a few grilled items. We have also started serving lunch, and we have opened six different locations across Wisconsin.

Our Specialties – Freshly Made and Masterfully Prepared Italian Cuisine

At Benvenuto’s Italian Grill, we offer a diverse selection of traditional Italian dishes. Some of our house specialties include our hand-stretched, wood-fired pizza, our daily fried fish, and our fresh salads and sides. To ensure that our guests never run out of new dishes to try, our featured menu rotates seasonally, changing four times per year. Try our famous meatballs topped with marinara sauce or our signature Italian salad!

We make it a point to use only fresh, quality ingredients in our dishes. Whenever we can, we source all-natural, Wisconsin-made products and try to use ingredients that don’t have additives or preservatives.

Our Commitment to Our Guests

Special Diets

Benvenuto’s Italian Grill is dedicated to giving our customers the best possible dining experience. This is why we strive to accommodate guests with special diets. If you have dietary restrictions or allergy concerns, don’t hesitate to tell our staff. We offer gluten-free, low-gluten, meatless, and low-carb menu options. Our restaurant even has a gluten-free menu that has been approved by the Gluten Intolerance Group ®.

Family Dining

Enjoy dining with the people dearest to your heart at Benvenuto’s Italian Grill. We take pride in catering to families while maintaining the casual yet elegant feel of our restaurant. All of our restaurant locations welcome children, and we go out of our way to create a family-friendly atmosphere. Kids are allowed to draw on the tablecloth, and they can order yummy meals from our special children’s menu.

Parties and Events

Do you need a venue for your special celebration? Come to Benvenuto’s Italian Grill. We would love to be a part of your rehearsal dinner, party, shower, or event. Most of our locations have private dining areas or party rooms available for you.

We also have special menus for groups of 10 or more, whether you host your event at our restaurant or order your meals to-go. For more information on our policy on large groups and parties, contact the restaurant location near you. 

Our Locations

You won’t have to travel too far to grab a bite of your favorite Italian meals. For your convenience, Benvenuto’s Italian Grill has six different locations all across Wisconsin. Visit a restaurant near you!

  • Beaver Dam

831 Park Ave.

Beaver Dam, WI 53916


Phone: 920-887-7994

Fax: 920-887-0116


  • Fitchburg

2949 Triverton Pike Dr.

Fitchburg, WI 53711


Phone: 608-278-7800

Fax: 608-278-0999


  • Fond du Lac

625 Rolling Meadows Dr.

Fond du Lac, WI 54937


Phone: 920-924-9112

Fax: 920-923-1366


  • Madison

1849 Northport Dr.

Madison, WI 53704


Phone: 608-241-1144

Fax: 608-241-0999


  • Middleton

1109 Fourier Dr.

Middleton, WI 53717


Phone: 608-826-0555

Fax: 608-826-0550


  • Oshkosh

300 S. Koeller St.

Oshkosh, WI 54902


Phone: 920-230-2300

Fax: 920-230-0999

Come and Dine With Us!

Have an unforgettable dining experience at Benvenuto’s Italian Grill. One taste of our delightful Italian dishes will surely leave you wanting more. Click here to learn about our rewards program. Bring your friends and family over to one of our locations today!