Mobile Menu

Italian Restaurant, Middleton

Italian food in Middleton

What do you expect upon entering an Italian restaurant in Middleton? Generally, Italian restaurants offer an exciting dining experience. As soon as you set foot inside one, the buzz of activity along with the aroma of herbs, olive oil, and other fresh ingredients will stir up your senses and prepare you for a hearty meal. 

Qualities of a Good Italian Restaurant in Middleton

You have to admit, though, that not all Italian restaurants in the country are the same. Some are simply less authentic than the others. So, when looking for an Italian restaurant in Middleton, remember the following:

A Good Italian Restaurant in Middleton Serves Great Food

When you hear the words “Italian restaurants,” pizza and pasta almost immediately come to mind. A good Italian restaurant in Middleton, however, serves more than just those two. Other delicious meals that offer a taste of Italy include risotto, ravioli, and some chicken or fish dishes. 

Other than having a variety of offerings, an honest-to-goodness Italian restaurant in Middleton prepares sumptuous meals with the food’s nutrition value in mind. Sure, Italian fare is known to be doughy and cheesy. At a good Italian restaurant, Middleton patrons are served with recipes that have healthy ingredients, like eggplant, zucchini, fresh basil, and ripe tomatoes to balance things out. 

A Good Italian Restaurant in Middleton Offers Different Sauce Options

A pasta dish is defined by its sauce, which not only adds a counterpoint flavor but also contributes to its textural and visual appeal. Whether you prefer the classic marinara sauce or a creamy Alfredo, a first-class Italian restaurant in Middleton should be able to satisfy your craving. 

A Good Italian Restaurant in Middleton Has a Warm and Welcoming Atmosphere

The staff of a first-rate Italian restaurant in Middleton knows the value of making customers feel at home. From the moment you walk through the door until you pay for your meal, they are warm and welcoming to patrons from all walks of life. 

A Good Italian Restaurant in Middleton Makes Customers Feel Comfortable

An Italian restaurant in Middleton provides ample seating as well as modern amenities so customers can fully enjoy their favorite Italian meals. Whether you’re hanging out with friends or having a romantic date, the finest Italian restaurant in Middleton will make you feel at easeon comfortable dining chairs and tables.

A Good Italian Restaurant in Middleton Has Enough Security

Businesses should ensure the safety of their customers. An Italian restaurant in Middleton is no different. The management should have a guarded parking space where you can park your car and remain safe so you can enjoy your meal with peace of mind. At a secure Italian restaurant, Middleton patrons can dine without worrying about their safety and of their property.

A Family-Friendly Italian Restaurant in Middleton 

If you are looking for a nice and homey Italian restaurant in Middleton that has the above-mentioned qualities, look no further than Benvenuto’s Italian Grill. We are a family-owned Italian restaurant that Middleton customers can visit not just to satisfy their craving for good food but also to spend time with their family. With a menu full of your favorite Italian dishes, we are the type of Italian restaurant in Middleton that has something for everyone.

The Best Italian Restaurant for Middleton Patrons

As your go-to Italian restaurant in Middleton, we offer a diverse selection of traditional favorites, including our famous meatballs topped with homemade marinara, baked tetrazzini, our signature Italian salad, and so much more. So, when looking for an Italian restaurant in Middleton, drop by Benvenuto’s Italian Grill. We are more than happy to serve you.

A Local Italian Restaurant in Middleton With a Heart

Benvenuto’s Italian Grill is a locally owned and operated Italian restaurant in Middleton. We make sure to source all natural and Wisconsin-made products whenever possible. In addition, we host “dine outs” to assist nonprofit charitable organizations and support their cause. You can read about why Italian food is so amazing here:

Benvenuto’s Italian Grill: Your Go-To Restaurant for Classic Italian Dishes

Are you in the mood for traditional Italian cuisine? Satisfy your cravings at Benvenuto’s Italian Grill. We have mastered the art of cooking traditional Italian dishes that are sure to please even the most sophisticated palates. You won’t be able to resist our savory pizzas or our creamy pastas. Lovingly made and perfectly seasoned, our culinary creations will have you savoring every last bite. 

Our Story – How the Italian Restaurant You Know and Love Came to Life

Benvenuto’s Italian Grill is a family-owned business in Wisconsin. Since we first opened our doors, we have been committed to providing outstanding food and exceptional service. Founded by Brian and Khristy Dominick, our first restaurant location was established in Beaver Dam, Wisconsin in 1996.

What started out as a dinner-only, Italian dining experience quickly grew into the thriving business it is today. Our menu once included only a handful of pasta dishes and a few wood-fired pizzas. Now, we offer a vast selection of expanded entrée options, individual dishes, and even a few grilled items. We have also started serving lunch, and we have opened six different locations across Wisconsin. 

Our Specialties – Freshly Made and Masterfully Prepared Italian Cuisine

At Benvenuto’s Italian Grill, we offer a diverse selection of traditional Italian dishes. Some of our house specialties include our hand-stretched, wood-fired pizza, our daily fried fish, and our fresh salads and sides. To ensure that our guests never run out of new dishes to try, our featured menu rotates seasonally, changing four times per year. Try our famous meatballs topped with marinara sauce or our signature Italian salad!

We make it a point to use only fresh, quality ingredients in our dishes. Whenever we can, we source all-natural, Wisconsin-made products and try to use ingredients that don’t have additives or preservatives.

Our Commitment to Our Guests

Special Diets

Benvenuto’s Italian Grill is dedicated to giving our customers the best possible dining experience. This is why we strive to accommodate guests with special diets. If you have dietary restrictions or allergy concerns, don’t hesitate to tell our staff. We offer gluten-free, low-gluten, meatless, and low-carb menu options. Our restaurant even has a gluten-free menu that has been approved by the Gluten Intolerance Group ®. 

Family Dining

Enjoy dining with the people dearest to your heart at Benvenuto’s Italian Grill. We take pride in catering to families while maintaining the casual yet elegant feel of our restaurant. All of our restaurant locations welcome children, and we go out of our way to create a family-friendly atmosphere. Kids are allowed to draw on the tablecloth, and they can order yummy meals from our special children’s menu. 

Parties and Events

Do you need a venue for your special celebration? Come to Benvenuto’s Italian Grill. We would love to be a part of your rehearsal dinner, party, shower, or event. Most of our locations have private dining areas or party rooms available for you. 

We also have special menus for groups of 10 or more, whether you host your event at our restaurant or order your meals to-go. For more information on our policy on large groups and parties, contact the restaurant location near you.

Our Locations

You won’t have to travel too far to grab a bite of your favorite Italian meals. For your convenience, Benvenuto’s Italian Grill has six different locations all across Wisconsin. Visit a restaurant near you!


  • Beaver Dam

831 Park Ave.

Beaver Dam, WI 53916


Phone: 920-887-7994

Fax: 920-887-0116


  • Fitchburg

2949 Triverton Pike Dr.

Fitchburg, WI 53711


Phone: 608-278-7800

Fax: 608-278-0999


  • Fond du Lac

625 Rolling Meadows Dr.

Fond du Lac, WI 54937


Phone: 920-924-9112

Fax: 920-923-1366


  • Madison

1849 Northport Dr.

Madison, WI 53704


Phone: 608-241-1144

Fax: 608-241-0999


  • Middleton

1109 Fourier Dr.

Middleton, WI 53717


Phone: 608-826-0555

Fax: 608-826-0550


  • Oshkosh

300 S. Koeller St.

Oshkosh, WI 54902


Phone: 920-230-2300

Fax: 920-230-0999

Come and Dine With Us!

Have an unforgettable dining experience at Benvenuto’s Italian Grill. One taste of our delightful Italian dishes will surely leave you wanting more. Click here to learn more about our gift cards. Bring your friends and family over to one of our locations today!